WNBA Commissioner Cathy Engelbert recently addressed the conversation surrounding Indiana Fever rookie Caitlin Clark's treatment in the league, emphasizing the rigorous adjustment process required for all rookies.

Appearing on Today with Hoda and Jenna on Thursday, Engelbert highlighted the contrast between NCAA basketball and the WNBA, noting, “I think our fans are adjusting. The fans we’ve had for a long time know we have the best, biggest, most physical, best players in the world.”

In college, there’s over 200 NCAA Division I college programs – there’s 12 WNBA teams. So you need to take the talent, and it’s centralized with the best, the biggest, the most physical, and really the best players in the world,” Engelbert added.

Her comments come amid ongoing discussions about Clark's experiences in the league, which some perceive as particularly challenging. While Engelbert praised Clark's achievements, such as being named Rookie of the Month for May, she stressed that the league's focus is not on any single player.

“There is a spotlight, and no league is ever about one player. You see players, there’s injuries, there’s other things that happen,” she said.

Is Caitlin Clark a victim of targeting

Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark (22) on the court in the first half against the Connecticut Sun at Mohegan Sun Arena.
David Butler II-USA TODAY Sports

Engelbert’s perspective contrasts with statements made by UConn women's basketball coach Geno Auriemma, who has suggested that Clark is being targeted in the WNBA. Auriemma pointed out that the physicality and defensive attention Clark faces might go beyond what is typical for a rookie, raising concerns about the fairness of her treatment.

“Every rookie has to go through the growing pains of being a professional basketball player. And the more attention you get, and today's world attention is No. 1 and attention brings money; so is she facing the rookie challenge, the rookie hardships that are inherent with being a rookie? Yes. She’s also being targeted,” Auriemma has said.

One such instance of perceived targeting involved Chicago Sky guard Chennedy Carter, who delivered a flagrant foul on Clark during an inbound play during the Sky’s game on June 1 vs. the Fever, sparking debate about whether Clark is being targeted.

Professional basketball opinions vary

Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark (22) reacts after being injured during the first half of an WNBA basketball game against the Connecticut Sun, Monday, May 20, 2024, at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.
© Doug McSchooler/for IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK

However, there are differing opinions within the world of professional basketball. Some argue that the physicality Clark is experiencing is a necessary adjustment for any player transitioning from college to professional basketball.

Adam Silver, NBA Commissioner, previously mentioned that “welcome to the league” moments are common for heralded rookies when asked about Clark, and that she is a tough player who can handle herself .

WNBA legend Sue Bird has highlighted the ongoing disrespect toward veteran players amid the attention on Clark.

Bird emphasized that while Clark's potential is undeniable, the immediate crowning of her as a top player can feel disrespectful to established WNBA athletes, pointing out the competitive nature of the league and the steep learning curve for rookies, regardless of their college success.

Despite the debates, Clark's early achievements in the WNBA are notable. Her designation as Rookie of the Month for May highlights her ability to compete at the WNBA level. She’s leading rookies in points, minutes and assists, with 16.3 points per game, an average of 33.7 minutes and averaging 6.6 assists, per the WNBA.

There's always an adjustment for all rookies. I think our rookie class this year is doing outstanding, including Caitlin,” Engelbert said.