Connor McDavid's Edmonton Oilers have been a perennial playoff contender for at least the past four seasons, whereas Jack Eichel's Buffalo Sabres didn't make the postseason once during his tenure in New York — but that all changed when he was traded to the Vegas Golden Knights in late 2021.

On Tuesday night, the No. 2 pick in the 2015 NHL Draft won a Stanley Cup before the No. 1 selection, a feat that few expected when the Oilers and Sabres went on completely different trajectories after both superstars were drafted nearly a decade ago.

But it was the American who had the last laugh, helping his Golden Knights capture their first title in just the franchise's sixth year in the National Hockey League.

It was Vegas who defeated Edmonton in six games in the Western Conference semifinals, before rolling over the Dallas Stars in the Western Conference Final and simply outplaying the Florida Panthers in the Stanley Cup Final.

The Golden Knights were one of the best teams in the league before they acquired Eichel, and afterwards, they were near unstoppable. That was proven at T-Mobile Arena in Game 5, as the Knights destroyed the Panthers 9-3 to win a ring in front of the home crowd.

Naturally, Twitter absolutely let McDavid have it after Eichel won a Stanley Cup before him:

Article Continues Below
More Vegas Golden Knights News
Ryan Lindgren surrounded by Avalanche, Golden Knights, Sabres, Flyers, and Blue Jackets logos
3 best Ryan Lindgren destinations in 2025 NHL free agencyChristopher Hennessy ·
Gustav-Nyquist-destinations-in-2025-NHL-free-agency
3 Best Gustav Nyquist destinations in 2025 NHL free agencyRB Hayek ·
Reilly Smith in a Kings Jersey, Los Angeles Kings logo and question marks around Smith, Golden Knights, Free Agent, NHL Free agency, Reilly Smith
3 best Reilly Smith destinations in 2025 NHL free agencyBryan Logan ·
Jonathan Drouin in a golden knights jersey with the golden knights logo plus quesiton marks around him , Avalanche, NHL Free Agency, Free Agent, Jonathan Drouin
3 best Jonathan Drouin destinations in 2025 NHL free agencyBryan Logan ·
Brandon Tanev in a Maple Leafs Jersey. Maple Leafs logo, questions marks around him, Jets, Brandon Tanev, Free Agent, NHL Free Agency
3 best Brandon Tanev destinations in 2025 NHL free agencyBryan Logan ·
image thumbnail
3 Golden Knights trade candidates after Oilers series lossChristopher Hennessy ·

Undoubtedly, Connor McDavid is a better player than Jack Eichel. But all that matters in professional hockey is Stanley Cups, and Eichel now has McDavid beat on that front.

The Western Conference is going to be electric for the next few seasons, and this probably isn't the last playoff matchup we see between McDavid's Oilers and Eichel's Golden Knights.

But it's now an uphill battle as the game's best player tries to finally get over the hump and accomplish what Jack Eichel did on Tuesday night.