Subscribe
Follow Us
Tensions flared early in Friday night’s matchup between the St. Louis Cardinals and San Diego Padres, as the benches cleared following a hit-by-pitch incident involving Cardinals first baseman Willson Contreras.
The drama unfolded in the bottom of the second inning when Padres starter Nick Pivetta hit Contreras on the arm with a 93.7 mph fastball. It was the 15th time Contreras has been plunked this season, and this one set him off. Clearly frustrated, Contreras turned to Pivetta and exchanged words while being restrained by Padres catcher Elias Diaz.
BENCHES CLEAR IN CARDS V PADRES🚨‼️ pic.twitter.com/VAF6TALHm1
— 𝓜𝓪𝔃𝔂𝓷🛸 (@MasynZyn) July 25, 2025
Contreras began walking toward first base, still jawing in the direction of the mound, prompting both dugouts and bullpens to spill onto the field in a full-blown confrontation. While no punches were thrown, players from both sides had to be separated in a heated scene that momentarily halted the game.
Cardinals looking for a spark in the standings after a fued with the Padres
The incident sparked particular intensity due to Contreras’ history with the Padres. As Cardinals beat writer John Denton noted, the veteran was hit by San Diego pitchers twice last season. One of those HBPs struck Contreras on the left hand, causing an injury that sidelined him for an extended period. That context likely explains why this latest hit—intentional or not—pushed Contreras over the edge.
Umpires acted quickly, issuing warnings to both teams in an attempt to prevent further escalation. The decision to warn both sides drew an animated response from Pivetta, who appeared visibly upset and shouted toward the umpiring crew. While he remained in the game, the warning served as a clear message: any further retaliation could result in ejections.
Contreras has developed a reputation for getting hit by pitches at an unusually high rate. This season’s total of 15 HBPs puts him among the league leaders in that category. His aggressive approach at the plate and willingness to crowd the strike zone often leave him vulnerable, but Friday’s confrontation suggests there may also be lingering bad blood between him and the Padres’ pitching staff.
Despite the chaos, cooler heads ultimately prevailed. Players returned to their dugouts without any further incident, and the game resumed shortly after. However, with this being the first of a multi-game series, all eyes will be on how both teams respond moving forward.
Whether it was an accident or something more deliberate, Contreras and the Cardinals clearly took exception to the pitch. And while the benches clearing didn’t lead to any ejections, the tension on the field was unmistakable.
As the series continues, the Cardinals and Padres may have more than just standings and stats on their minds. The spark has been lit—now it's a question of whether either side fans the flames.
