Tyrese Haliburton didn’t need pyrotechnics or a choreographed celebration to announce his presence. He just needed a smile and one legendary line: “It’s gotta be the shoes,” per ESPN. That line, delivered coolly to reporters postgame, echoed louder than any trash talk he could’ve cooked up. With one quote, Haliburton linked himself to a sacred piece of NBA lore, Michael Jordan and Spike Lee’s iconic Nike ads, and planted himself firmly in the Knicks-Pacers rivalry’s next chapter.

On a night dripping with symbolism and stardom—Reggie Miller, Patrick Ewing, Larry Johnson, and Spike Lee all in the building—Haliburton gave the Knicks a villain worth booing. He dropped 31 points, dished out 11 assists, grabbed four boards, and had a pivotal steal. But it wasn’t just the stat line. It was the cold-blooded poise. It was the deep three with seconds to spare. It was the mic drop line that made even Spike Lee smirk, whether he wanted to or not.

Game 1 was headed for the books as another Knicks home win. They were up nine with less than a minute left. But then came Aaron Nesmith’s fourth-quarter eruption, Indiana’s defensive traps, and finally, Haliburton’s calm orchestration of chaos. According to Elias Sports Bureau, NBA playoff teams were previously 0-1,414 when trailing by nine or more in the final minute. That streak’s over now. Haliburton’s squad made history.

The Flash and the Pressure Shift

Related NewsArticle continues below
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13) before the game against the Detroit Lions at Levi's Stadium.
49ers’ Brock Purdy drops Pacers-Knicks hint amid Tyrese Haliburton mania
Philadelphia 76ers guard Jared McCain (20) holds his head next to Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton (0) after a hard fall during the third quarter.
Jared McCain’s insane reaction to Haliburton’s shot to force OT

This wasn’t just a win. It was a message. Indiana now leads 1-0, flipping the pressure squarely onto New York’s shoulders. The Knicks entered Game 1 as 6.5-point favorites. After the collapse? Oddsmakers shaved that down to 5.5. The weight of letting one slip at home, in front of the ghosts of playoff heartbreaks past, is real.

But Indiana doesn’t care about ghosts. Not when Tyrese Haliburton is channeling legends and rewriting scripts. That Game 1 finish wasn’t an accident. It was crafted by someone who’s studied the NBA’s culture, who respects the art of a rivalry, and who understands the value of a well-timed jab.

And with MSG watching, he landed it.