With the shocking firing of New York Knicks head coach Tom Thibodeau, people have been speculating who made the final call on the decision, whether it was owner James Dolan or president Leon Rose. While the firing of Thibodeau by the Knicks set the basketball world ablaze, some insiders aren't buying the team's spin on the matter.

In the latest blog post by NBA insider Marc Stein, he said that New York has “painted” the firing as a mainly Rose decision, but he reports that “few in league circles seem to be buying it.” If anything, Dolan was believed not to be a fan of the team's “organizational dynamics.”

“The Knicks have painted this as a Leon Rose-led decision, but few in league circles seem to be buying it. Rose and Thibodeau were close long before Rose became the Knicks' lead basketball decision-maker in March 2020,” Stein wrote. “The Knicks, in fact, hired Thibs as their new coach entering the 2020-21 season at Rose's strong insistence.”

“Dolan, meanwhile, has long been described by league observers well-acquainted with New York's organizational dynamics as a non-fan … which some attribute to Thibodeau's connections as a staff member to what one source described as ‘the old Knicks,'” Stein wrote. “It's a reference to the Knicks' teams coached by Jeff Van Gundy in the late 1990s that, until the past five seasons with Thibs in charge, stood as the last previous successful era of Knicks basketball.”

Other reports had it as a mutual decision by the Knicks for the firing

Article Continues Below
More New York Knicks News
2025 NBA Draft Big Board First Round
New York Knicks 2025 NBA Draft grade for pick No. 51Drew Maresca ·
Leon Rose, Mohamed Diawara, New York Knicks logo with Madison Square Garden behind them
Knicks draft intriguing French prospect after Clippers tradeKris Pursiainen ·
LA Clippers forward Kawhi Leonard (2) looks to post up against New York Knicks forward OG Anunoby (8) in the fourth quarter at Madison Square Garden.
Clippers trade with New York Knicks amid day 2 of NBA DraftTomer Azarly ·
New York Knicks assistant coach Rick Brunson talks with New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11), forward Mikal Bridges (25), and guard Josh Hart (3) during a timeout in the third quarter against the Boston Celtics at Madison Square Garden.
Knicks rumors: Will NY add another former Villanova player with 50th pick in draft?Jackson Stone ·
Charlotte Hornets head coach James Borrego tries to calm down his team from the sideline during the second half against the Washington Wizards at Spectrum Center.
Knicks granted permission to interview ex-Hornets head coachBenedetto Vitale ·
Jamir Watkins Florida State next to New York Knicks logo. Madison Square Garden in the background, blue stripe at the bottom
Sources: Another Knicks 2025 NBA Draft target emergesKris Pursiainen ·
New York Knicks head coach Tom Thibodeau looks on prior to game six of the eastern conference finals against the Indiana Pacers for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.
Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images

As many will debate who with the Knicks was responsible for the firing of Thibodeau, one other note that Stein would mention was how Dolan was involved in exit meetings with “select players,” which was said to be rare. Though people are debating between Rose and Dolan, ESPN's Shams Charania would say that it was both who came up with the path that the team “needed a new voice,” as he said on The Pat McAfee Show.

“As soon as the season ended, they started meetings internally, and James Dolan and Leon Rose, they believed the best path for this team to take the next step to win a championship was that they needed a new voice,” Charania said. “So Leon Rose and James Dolan came to the decision this morning that they were going to part ways with Tom Thibodeau. He's fired as their head coach.”

Initial reporting from Ian Begley would say that Rose made the call with Dolan's support via his work with SNY, so the coverage seems to have a plethora of ideas. Now, the Knicks look to find a new head coach to build off this past Eastern Conference Finals berth.