The College Football Playoff committee released their first rankings for the College Football Playoff on Tuesday. These rankings are hardly ever sticky. Every year, someone outside of the top four finds their way into the playoff despite the odds for that particular team making it seeming minuscule. It always happens, so one should be surprised when it happens again.

Now that the rankings are out, however, it is fun to go through and parse those rankings out. That's largely the purpose for these rankings right now; the playoff doesn't start until late December anyway. There is still a month of the regular season to go, and lot of things will happen between now and then.

With that being said, why not look at the rankings to try to find teams that maybe the committee has a little too much faith in. Three teams in particular stand out as teams that the College Football Playoff Committee may have overrated.

Michigan Wolverines (No. 3)

Michigan's Jim Harbaugh

The committee ranked the Michigan Wolverines third in their initial College Football Playoff rankings. Looking at data, Michigan sure seems like one of the three best teams in the country, just like the committee has it. Michigan's defense has allowed the fewest yards per game (226.8) and points per game (5.9) in the country. Their offense, while far from perfect, does rank sixth in the country in points per game as well (40.6).

So, why would they be overrated?

They might not be! But if one were to make the case, one reason could be their schedule. Michigan hasn't beaten anybody worth a darn so far this season. Michigan hasn't played anybody that was ranked in the committee's initial top 25 College Football Playoff rankings.

Their best win on the season has been. .. Rutgers? Outside of the Scarlet Knights, who are 6-2 on the season, the Big Ten opponents Michigan has played and beaten have been Minnesota, Nebraska, Indiana, and Michigan State. Those four teams are a combined 14-18 on the season. Granted, Michigan has blown all of those teams out, but that isn't a murderers' row by any stretch.

Also, there is just a lot going on with the Michigan program right now. Before the season, head coach Jim Harbaugh was suspended for the first three games for recruiting violations. Now, the program is involved with an elaborate sign-stealing scandal that is too convoluted to point out here.

Michigan doesn't have a signature win yet. Teams like Oregon, Washington, and Florida State do without this extra baggage. They should be ranked ahead of Michigan in the College Football Playoff rankings.

Ole Miss Rebels (No. 10)

Ole Miss football, Rebels, LSU football, Lane Kiffin, transfer portal

Article Continues Below
More NCAA Football News
Detail view of the logo and basketballs during NCAA Tournament West Regional Practice at Chase Center.
Former NCAA athletes to be paid $2.8 billion for lost NIL earningsBenjamin Adducchio ·
MLB's Senior Vice President & Deputy General Counsel Investigations, Compliance & Security, Bryan Seeley, speaks to our editorial board about sports gambling.
Former MLB exec to be new head of College Sports CommissionTroy Finnegan ·
A view of the NCAA logo and trophy before the 2025 Women's National Gymnastics Championship at Dickies Arena.
Judge approves NCAA House Settlement allowing schools to pay playersTroy Finnegan ·
Oregon Ducks wide receiver Evan Stewart (7) gives the football to a referee after scoring a touchdown during the first half against the Michigan State Spartans at Autzen Stadium.
Oregon football’s Evan Stewart gets clarity on diagnosis, timetable for severe injuryTroy Finnegan ·
The menu screen for Tennessee versus Oklahoma on EA Sports College Football 25. After 100 simulations, the game favored the Volunteers to win in Norman, Oklahoma. Mandatory Credit: © Keenan Thomas/Knoxville News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
NCAA football news: Gamers can help their team earn NIL money on College Football 26Zachary Draves ·
Oregon wide receiver Evan Stewart walks the field during warmups as the Oregon Ducks face the Ohio State Buckeyes Wednesday, Jan. 1, 2025, in the quarterfinal of the College Football Playoff at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, Calif.
Oregon football’s star WR ‘feared to have suffered significant injury’Jaren Kawada ·

Much like Michigan, what exactly is Ole Miss' signature win? The Rebels do have two wins over teams ranked in the initial College Football Playoff rankings in Tulane and LSU. But neither win looked as good on the film as it does on paper.

That's fine; Ole Miss shouldn't apologize for winning the games on their schedule. And both of those teams are good! LSU has one of the best offenses in the entire country! Tulane might be the best non-Power Five team in the country! They're good!

However, Tulane was down their starting quarterback in Michael Pratt, who is one of the most underrated quarterbacks in the country, and a late fumble touchdown made that game look a little more lopsided than it actually was. The Rebels were losing by nine points at home with eight minutes to go in their shootout win over LSU. Bad teams like Auburn and Arkansas hung around the Rebels in their next couple of games.

Ole Miss is a very good team, but they might not be the 10th-best team in the country and shouldn't be there in the College Football Playoff rankings.

UCLA Bruins (No. 19)

NCAA clock, Chip Kelly Clock, UCLA football, Chip Kelly, NCAA

UCLA also doesn't exactly have a signature win on their ledger this season. They don't have a win in two tries against teams ranked in the top 25 in Utah and Oregon State.

Freshman phenom Dante Moore has struggled mightily in conference play and has seemingly been benched. His future is very bright, but he looked a bit overwhelmed in conference play.

While UCLA could easily finish undefeated the rest of the way, this team just isn't that good and is clearly overrated in the College Football Playoff rankings.