The Tampa Bay Buccaneers' recent announcement of Baker Mayfield's $100 million deal has undeniably become one of the most contentious topics in the NFL, splitting the fanbase right down the middle. This significant investment in the quarterback has ignited a firestorm of reactions from fans, with social media platforms, especially X, becoming a battleground of opinions. Fans took to Twitter to voice their thoughts, ranging from ecstatic celebrations of the team's ambitions to skepticism about the value Mayfield brings to the Buccaneers.

One segment of the fanbase is exuberant, seeing this deal as a definitive step towards Super Bowl contention. A fan, @jynxzi, succinctly encapsulated this optimism by proclaiming the team as “SUPER BOWL BOUND” shortly after the announcement. Echoing this sentiment, @OCPDesigns expressed their approval, stating Mayfield “Deserves every penny of it,” highlighting a section of the fanbase that views the quarterback's contract as a just reward for his potential to lead the team to glory.

Conversely, some fans question the prudence of such a hefty financial commitment to Mayfield. @bealo_ critiqued the move as an “overpay” for a player they consider “mid,” implying that Mayfield's performance does not justify the substantial investment. This sentiment was visually echoed by @khamszn, who compared the Buccaneers' spending to overpaying for aging stars, using a “lebron laughing meme” to underscore the skepticism.

Yet, there's also a narrative of redemption and opportunity among the fans. @mq_1predator pointed out, “Too many teams gave up on him. There's a reason he was so hyped up coming into the league,” reflecting a belief in Mayfield's underlying talent and potential that has perhaps been overlooked or undervalued by his previous teams.

@Cory_Hays407 and @RM_Cao highlighted Mayfield's resilience and the results of his leadership. Cory_Hays407 noted, “He deserves it after last season. Projected to win 3 games by many and instead won the NFC South and a playoff game. Keeping our core together is great. Continuity is key,” emphasizing Mayfield's role in surpassing expectations and valuing continuity in team composition. RM_Cao admired Mayfield's gamble on himself: “Bro bet on himself and it worked. Fair play 🤑,” acknowledging the quarterback's self-belief and the payoff it has brought.

RECOMMENDED (Article Continues Below)
GM Jason Licht in the middle, Jackson Powers-Johnson, Marshawn Kneeland, Malik Washington around him, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers wallpaper in the background

Enzo Flojo ·

The diversity in fan reactions underscores the high stakes and polarizing nature of NFL signings, particularly those involving substantial sums and high-profile players like Mayfield. From expressions of disbelief and criticism to accolades and affirmations of faith in Mayfield's potential, the Buccaneers' fanbase is a microcosm of the broader NFL community's divergent views on player valuation and team building strategies.

As the Buccaneers prepare for the upcoming season with Mayfield under this new lucrative deal, as well as Mike Evans resigned, these varied fan reactions will set the backdrop against which his performance and the team's fortunes will be evaluated. Whether this split in the fanbase will heal or widen further will depend much on the field's outcomes, making the upcoming season one of the most scrutinized in recent Buccaneers history.