On Tuesday, EA Sports released their top 25 rankings for the toughest places to play in their upcoming video game, College Football 25, and some are already calling for a software patch update.
Keep in mind that no matter how the video game developers or anyone else's list is determined, there are going to be debates about the perceived nerve or cluelessness of the person putting together the list. But this one certainly came with surprises, even if it is technically a video game we're talking about here, and not real life. However, even in a video game ranking like this, it's supposed to be a direct reflection of these teams and the difficulty of the venues they play in. That's why many are labeling this list erroneous.
EA Sports College Football 25 top 25 toughest places to play
- Kyle Field – Texas A&M
- Bryant-Denny Stadium – Alabama
- Tiger Stadium – LSU
- Ohio Stadium – Ohio State
- Sanford Stadium – Georgia
- Beaver Stadium – Penn State
- Camp Randall Stadium – Wisconsin
- Gaylord Family Oklahoma Memorial Stadium – Oklahoma
- Doak S. Campbell Stadium – Florida State
- Ben Hill Griffin Stadium – Florida
- Autzen Stadium – Oregon
- Memorial Stadium – Clemson
- Neyland Stadium – Tennessee
- Jordan-Hare Stadium – Auburn
- Williams-Brice Stadium – South Carolina
- Michigan Stadium – Michigan
- Lane Stadium – Virginia Tech
- Rice-Eccles Stadium – Utah
- Darrell K. Royal – Texas Memorial Stadium – Texas
- Kinnick Stadium – Iowa
- Notre Dame Stadium – Notre Dame
- Spartan Stadium – Michigan State
- Donald W. Reynolds Razorback Stadium – Arkansas
- Albertsons Stadium – Boise State
- Davis Wade Stadium – Mississippi State
Here's how the developers of EA Sports College Football 25 decided upon their top 25 rankings:
“We laid out the significant impact that Homefield Advantage can have on the outcome of games in EA SPORTS™ College Football 25 during our Gameplay Deep Dive Campus Huddle. Audio and in-game modifiers such as blurred routes, incorrect play art, confidence and composure effects, and screen shaking are some of the immersive impacts away teams and players will be forced to contend with.
“But not all Homefield Advantages are created equal. The Development Team worked to compile a list of the Top 25 Toughest Places to Play, factoring in historical stats such as home winning %, home game attendance, active home winning streaks, team prestige, and more.”
EA Sports has said that these rankings are subject to change with future updates, but perhaps an update should come sooner rather than later.
Starting with No. 1, Texas A&M's Kyle Field, it's not the most shocking but there's definitely room for argument. The 12th Man is truly something to see when traveling to Aggieland, along with their plethora of other traditions, so College Station deserves to be near the top. However, most, like Josh Pate and other analysts, would argue LSU deserves the top crown.
Keeping in the top 10, it's puzzling how high Georgia football and their home of Sanford Stadium is at No. 5. The Bulldogs just barely made it into my top five SEC stadiums, much less the top five in the country. While, yes, they've won back-to-back national championships in the last three years and are considered one of the most talented teams in the country, there are much tougher places to play than in Athens.
Florida State football getting the nod over Florida at No. 9 while the Gators finished the top 10 was strange as well. Many consider Ben Hill Griffin Stadium, otherwise known as The Swamp, one of the top five toughest venues in the country. The Seminoles' Doak Campbell Stadium is probably one of the best in the ACC, but even then it's not the best in the conference. That's what also makes Clemson's No. 12 ranking questionable. Even compiling all of EA Sports' factors in, Clemson's Memorial Stadium is still the best in the conference.
As for a snub, what about Nebraska's Memorial Stadium being left off the list? Sure, things for the Cornhuskers haven't been going the way they've wanted to for over two decades now, but it still has historical relevance and great attendance.
So, with that said, let's fix EA Sports College Football 25's top 25 toughest places to play list with our own.
Re-Ranking EA Sports College Football 25 top 25 toughest places to play
These rankings reflect a combination of EA Sports' criteria and additional factors that contribute to the overall difficulty of playing in these stadiums.
1. Tiger Stadium – LSU – Known as Death Valley, this stadium offers an unparalleled atmosphere with deafening noise levels, passionate fans, and a rich history of memorable games.
2. Neyland Stadium – Tennessee – The Volunteers' home field advantage is boosted by the stadium's size — 100,000-plus — and energetic fans.
3. Kyle Field – Texas A&M – The 12th Man creates an intimidating environment for any visiting team, complemented by the Aggies' numerous traditions.
4. Beaver Stadium – Penn State – Known for its Whiteout games, the energy and noise in this stadium can be overwhelming for visiting teams.
5. Ben Hill Griffin Stadium – Florida – The Swamp's heat and humidity, combined with passionate fans, create one of the toughest environments in college football.
6. Autzen Stadium – Oregon – Despite its smaller size (54,000), the noise levels and enthusiastic fan base make it a challenging venue for opponents.
7. Michigan Stadium – Michigan – The Big House's sheer size (107,601) and history make it a difficult place for opponents.
8. Memorial Stadium – Clemson – Known as Death Valley, this stadium is one of the toughest in the ACC, with a rabid fan base and strong home field advantage.
9. Husky Stadium – Washington – The noise from the enclosed design and passionate fans create a challenging environment.
10. Ohio Stadium – Ohio State – With a seating capacity of over 100,000 and an electric atmosphere, the Horseshoe is one of the most daunting places to play.
11. Jordan-Hare Stadium – Auburn – The fierce Auburn fan base and the tradition of the “War Eagle” flight make Jordan-Hare Stadium an intimidating venue for any opponent.
12. Sanford Stadium – Georgia – The “Between the Hedges” tradition and the passionate Bulldogs fans create a formidable atmosphere at Sanford Stadium, but College Football 25's No. 5 ranking was just too high.
13. Doak Campbell Stadium – Florida State – With the iconic “Tomahawk Chop” and a loud, dedicated fan base, Doak Campbell Stadium is a challenging place for visiting teams.
14. Rice-Eccles Stadium – Utah – The high altitude and the fervent support of the Utes fans make Rice-Eccles Stadium a tough environment for opponents.
15. Bryant-Denny Stadium – Alabama – The Crimson Tide's consistent success and a sea of cheering fans make Bryant-Denny Stadium one of the toughest venues in college football.
16. Notre Dame Stadium – Notre Dame – The storied history and the “Play Like a Champion Today” sign inspire the Fighting Irish and their fans, creating a challenging setting for visitors.
17. Camp Randall Stadium – Wisconsin – The “Jump Around” tradition and a raucous crowd make Camp Randall Stadium a difficult place for any visiting team.
18. Gaylord Family Oklahoma Memorial Stadium – Oklahoma – The Sooners' enthusiastic fan base and the “Boomer Sooner” chant provide a significant home-field advantage.
19. Darrell K. Royal – Texas Memorial Stadium – Texas – With its large capacity and passionate Longhorns fans, Darrell K. Royal – Texas Memorial Stadium is a daunting venue for opponents.
20. Lane Stadium – Virginia Tech – The “Enter Sandman” entrance and the intense support of the Hokies fans make Lane Stadium a tough place to play.
21. Williams-Brice Stadium – South Carolina – The “Sandstorm” tradition and the energy of the Gamecocks fans create a formidable atmosphere at Williams-Brice Stadium.
22. Spartan Stadium – Michigan State – The Spartans' passionate fan base and traditions make this a tough place to play, especially in big games.
23. Memorial Stadium – Nebraska – The loyalty of the Cornhuskers fans and the “Sea of Red” provide a significant home-field advantage at Memorial Stadium. And unlike College Football 25's list, I'm adding Nebraska into ours.
24. Kidd Brewer Stadium – Appalachian State – The high elevation and the fervent support of the Mountaineers fans make Kidd Brewer Stadium a challenging environment.
25. Kinnick Stadium – Iowa – The “Kinnick Wave” and the passionate Hawkeyes fans make Kinnick Stadium a tough place to play, particularly during night games.
Like anything else with sports, these are all subjective, of course. But as the season goes on, I'd expect EA Sports College Football 25 to heavily adjust their list.
Follow Us
Subscribe
