The 2024 campaign for Saquon Barkley was historic. He became just the eighth running back in NFL history to surpass 2,000 rushing yards. His feat was undeniably impressive, but it has sparked debate about the factors behind his success, particularly the role of Philadelphia’s elite offensive line.

Statistically, Barkley’s efficiency was his calling card. He averaged 5.8 yards per carry (YPC), ranking fourth among all 2,000-yard rushers in NFL history, behind legends like O.J. Simpson, Adrian Peterson, and Barry Sanders. However, his achievement wasn’t just about personal brilliance. Metrics like yards-before-contact (YBC) per carry reveal how much Barkley benefited from his environment. His 3.8 YBC was the highest in the league and far above the NFL average of 2.5. In contrast, Derrick Henry’s 2020 2,000-yard season saw him achieve the milestone with an average YBC of just 2.5.

The Eagles’ offensive line was another key factor. Ranked first by Pro Football Focus (PFF), the unit provided Barkley with exceptional blocking, a luxury most other 2,000-yard rushers didn’t have. This same offensive line has a history of elevating running backs; previous Eagles rushers, including Miles Sanders and DeAndre Swift, saw significant statistical drop-offs after leaving Philadelphia.

Was Derrick Henry the best RB in the NFL in 2024?

Baltimore Ravens running back Derrick Henry (22) runs to score a touchdown against the Pittsburgh Steelers in the third quarter in an AFC wild card game at M&T Bank Stadium.
Tommy Gilligan-Imagn Images

Barkley’s season wasn’t without flaws, however. His first-down conversion rate of 23.8% was solid but not elite, ranking ninth among running backs with at least 200 carries. His running style also proved volatile, as he led the NFL with 46 runs of 10+ yards and seven of 40+ yards but suffered 33 tackles for loss, the second-most in the league.

Comparing Barkley to his peers further complicates the picture. Henry, for instance, posted a higher YPC (5.9) and outperformed Barkley in metrics like total yards above expectation (562 to 549) and per-carry efficiency (1.77 to 1.62). Henry also faced loaded defensive boxes on 33.23% of his carries compared to Barkley’s 20.58%, suggesting he succeeded in tougher circumstances.

Barkley’s journey to 2,000 yards was undoubtedly aided by the Eagles’ infrastructure, but that doesn’t diminish his talent. From his time with the New York Giants to his record-breaking plays in 2024, including a backward hurdle against the Jaguars, Barkley has consistently showcased rare athleticism.

Still, the question lingers: How much of his success was Barkley, and how much was the system? The debate underscores the broader issue of balancing individual performance with the supporting cast. As one recent poll indicated, many fans credit Barkley’s offensive line more than his abilities. Ultimately, Barkley’s 2024 season was remarkable but not without context—a blend of elite talent and optimal conditions.