Subscribe
Follow Us
The Detroit Tigers are nervously awaiting the health verdict on Kerry Carpenter, their playoff hero, whose participation in the winner-take-all Game 5 of the AL Division Series against the Cleveland Guardians hangs in the balance.
Carpenter, instrumental in the Tigers' current postseason run, is currently sidelined with a hamstring injury that he sustained in a pivotal moment of Game 4. As the series returns to Detroit all squared up, his availability could decisively influence the outcome.
Carpenter, who clinched Game 2 with a dramatic three-run homer, aggravated his hamstring while scoring a crucial run in Thursday night’s encounter, which saw the Guardians eventually prevail 5-4. The incident has left the Tigers and their fans anxiously wondering whether he can contribute to what promises to be a fiercely contested Game 5.
“Kerry Carpenter will test out his hamstring today and tomorrow before the Tigers decide his status for Game 5. ‘We’re gonna take as much time as we can to see what he can and can’t handle,' A.J. Hinch said.” via Jason Beck in X, formerly Twitter.
Kerry Carpenter might be out for game 5
This challenge is compounded by a last-minute schedule change due to weather concerns with MLB moving the start time from the evening to early afternoon. This adjustment reduces the window for Carpenter's recovery and testing, placing additional pressure on the team's preparations.
Carpenter’s heroics have been a highlight of the Tigers' season. Beyond his pivotal postseason performances, he also contributed 18 home runs in just 87 games during the regular season, an impressive tally especially considering he missed time with a stress fracture in his lower back.
Article Continues Below
His power and presence in the lineup have been key factors in the club's offensive strategy, and his absence would undoubtedly be felt.
If Carpenter is deemed unable to play and needs to be replaced on the roster, the Tigers would face not only the immediate challenge of filling his spot in the lineup but also longer-term implications.
MLB rules stipulate that if he is replaced, he would be ineligible to play in the ALCS should Detroit advance to face the New York Yankees, adding another layer of strategic complexity to Hinch’s decision-making.
Bligh Madris stands as a potential replacement if Carpenter cannot go. Having spent the series working out in Toledo, Madris is ready to step in. He batted .269 in 21 games for the Tigers this season and, while he offers a solid option, the drop-off from Carpenter’s postseason heroics would be significant.
“There is no series if you don’t win tomorrow,” emphasized Hinch.
Every decision now is geared toward that must-win game with the hope that Carpenter can somehow contribute to a Tigers victory that keeps their season alive. The next few hours will be critical as the team assesses their star player’s health and strategizes for the biggest game of their year.
