Subscribe
Follow Us
The New York Yankees, perennial contenders with a championship-or-bust mentality, find themselves at a critical juncture in the 2025 season. Despite a formidable lineup, the glaring hole at third base has become impossible to ignore. Oswaldo Cabrera's injury and DJ LeMahieu's just returning to the lineup have left the hot corner as a clear weak spot for a team with World Series ambitions. Meanwhile, the St. Louis Cardinals, though surprisingly competitive, continue to explore avenues to move Nolan Arenado and his sizable contract, especially after he exercised his no-trade clause to block a deal to Houston this past winter. With both teams’ needs perfectly aligned, the stage is set for a blockbuster trade that could reshape the playoff landscape.
Why the Yankees and Arenado Are a Perfect Match
Nolan Arenado remains one of the game’s premier third basemen, boasting elite defense and a proven track record as a run producer. Even after a down year in 2024, he’s rebounded in 2025, displaying the kind of power and leadership that made him an eight-time All-Star and 10-time Gold Glove winner. For the Yankees, Arenado represents not just an upgrade at third base but a transformational piece who could anchor the infield and lengthen a lineup already featuring Aaron Judge, Anthony Volpe, and Giancarlo Stanton.
Arenado’s contract, with roughly $74 million owed over the next three seasons, is a significant commitment, but the Yankees have both the financial muscle and the motivation to absorb it, especially with the Cardinals likely to include cash to offset the cost. The Yankees are also on Arenado’s short list of approved destinations, and the presence of friends and former teammates like Paul Goldschmidt and DJ LeMahieu in New York only adds to the appeal. For Arenado, the chance to chase a championship in the Bronx could be the incentive needed to waive his no-trade clause, a hurdle that derailed previous talks with Houston.
For St. Louis, moving Arenado is about more than just shedding payroll. The Cardinals are in a transitional phase, balancing the desire to remain competitive with the need to infuse young talent into their roster. Arenado’s contract is backloaded, and with the Rockies still paying a portion, the financial relief from a trade would be substantial. More importantly, the Cardinals are targeting controllable, high-upside prospects, particularly pitching and middle infield talent, to jumpstart their next competitive window.
The Perfect Trade Proposal
The ideal trade must satisfy both teams’ needs: the Yankees receive a superstar third baseman, while the Cardinals get a package of premium prospects and financial relief. Here’s the proposal that checks every box:
Yankees Receive: Nolan Arenado
Cardinals Receive: Bryce Cunningham, Roderick Arias, and Cam Schlitter
The Yankees acquire Nolan Arenado, with the Cardinals sending $25 million to help cover the remaining salary. In return, St. Louis receives three of New York’s top prospects: right-handed pitcher Bryce Cunningham, shortstop Roderick Arias, and right-handed pitcher Cam Schlitter.
This package gives the Cardinals exactly what they need. Cunningham is a high-ceiling arm with frontline potential, and Arias is a dynamic young infielder with the tools to become a future star. Schlitter, meanwhile, adds further depth to a pitching staff in need of upside. The inclusion of $25 million from the Cardinals makes the deal palatable for the Yankees, ensuring that Arenado’s contract won’t hamstring their future payroll flexibility.
For the Yankees, this trade is the ultimate win-now move. Arenado’s glove instantly stabilizes the infield, and his bat deepens a lineup that has struggled to find consistency at third base. The Yankees have the resources to absorb the financial hit, especially with St. Louis covering a portion of the salary, and the prospect cost is justified by the immediate upgrade and the championship window that Arenado helps extend.
For the Cardinals, the return is precisely what they need to remain competitive while building for the future. Cunningham and Schlitter offer much-needed pitching depth, while Arias could become a cornerstone infielder. The financial relief allows St. Louis to reallocate resources and potentially address other areas of need, whether at the trade deadline or in the offseason.
One factor that could drive up the price is competition from other contenders. The Dodgers, also on Arenado’s approved list, are expected to be aggressive if Arenado becomes available, potentially sparking a bidding war that forces the Yankees to sweeten their offer. However, the Yankees’ willingness to part with top prospects and absorb salary puts them in a strong position to close the deal.
The Yankees’ perfect Nolan Arenado trade proposal is a win-win for both franchises. With Arenado’s no-trade clause no longer an insurmountable obstacle and both teams’ needs perfectly aligned, this is the blockbuster move that could define the 2025 season, for the Yankees, the missing piece in their World Series quest; for the Cardinals, a bold step toward their next era of contention.
