Subscribe
Follow Us
The Cleveland Cavaliers’ season, once filled with promise and historic highs, came to a sobering halt in Game 5 of the Eastern Conference Semifinals. A 114-105 loss to the Indiana Pacers at Rocket Arena sealed a 4-1 second-round series defeat, and with it, the Cavs' early playoff exit for the third consecutive year.
After a 64-win regular season, the second-most in franchise history, expectations in Northeast Ohio had never been higher since LeBron James’ departure. But for all the dominance they displayed from October through April, the Cavs faltered when it mattered most.
No one took it harder than Donovan Mitchell. Playing through a painful ankle sprain re-aggravated during Game 4, Mitchell poured in 35 points across 38 grueling minutes. He added nine rebounds, four steals, and a block. He did everything he could, even on one leg, to extend Cleveland’s season. But it wasn’t enough.
“We took a step in the right direction, but we didn’t win a championship and we didn’t complete the end goal,” Mitchell said. “There are no moral victories here. We just didn’t get the job done.”
Donovan Mitchell and the Cavs started Game 5 strong
Cleveland opened Game 5 strong, racing out to a 19-point lead behind Mitchell’s aggressive first-quarter surge. But that advantage crumbled. Indiana’s relentless pace, depth, and resolve, led by Tyrese Haliburton’s 31 points, proved too much. The Pacers took control with a 28-12 third-quarter burst and never looked back.
It marked another playoff disappointment in Mitchell’s Cavs tenure. Since arriving in Cleveland, the superstar guard has helped the franchise to 163 regular-season wins and two playoff series victories. But the Cavs have now failed to advance beyond the Eastern Conference semifinals for the third straight year. However, given all the context surrounding this matchup, this early exit hurts more.
This was supposed to be different. The Cavs looked like legitimate contenders for most of the season, boasting the East’s top seed, a dominant point differential, and one of the league’s most dynamic offenses. But injuries to Darius Garland and Evan Mobley, poor shooting, and late-game collapses haunted them in this series. They were 0-3 at home, a bitter pill for a franchise that had prided itself on its dominance in Rocket Arena.
“Don’t want to believe it,” Mitchell said. “It’s tough to win in this league. We didn’t do the things necessary. I love playing in that (expletive) arena. That energy. That crowd. We were 0-3 at home. Let the city down. This place is special. This place is really special. And we didn’t get it done. That’s what hurts.”
Cleveland believes they'll be back next season
The boos that rained down in the second half reflected more than frustration, they echoed years of unmet expectations. Fans were promised a new era of relevance. Instead, they were left with familiar heartbreak.
Head coach Kenny Atkinson, overseeing his first postseason with the Cavs, offered a deep assessment of what went wrong for Cleveland.
“They were the better team. They deserved it, they played great,” Atkinson said. “I do feel like we got better, and from a team aspect, and then we had a lot of individuals make a step. But the truth of the matter is, we didn’t get to the level we wanted. We’re not pleased with that, and we’re not celebrating the season. We’ve got to figure out this last piece, how to get over this hump. I was, quite honestly, expecting more. It’s disappointing.”
However, despite the bitter ending, Mitchell stood tall, defiant in the face of doubt.
“I believe in everyone in that locker room,” Mitchell said. “Ya’ll gonna write us off, man. We’ll be back.”
The Cavs must now reckon with the brutal truth. Despite 64 wins, an MVP-caliber stretch from Mitchell, and months of dominant basketball, it all amounted to an early exit. A dream season, undone in five painful games. Sure, injuries and misfortune played their roles. But so did inconsistency, mental lapses, and missed opportunities.
Mitchell knows that. So do his teammates. So does the city. But now that the season is over, it's clear that the goals were unmet and that the narrative remains unchanged.
However, if Mitchell’s words carry the weight of his performance, then the Cavs aren’t going away without a fight. They have to prove that this isn't what they're capable of.
“We’re a good team,” Mitchell admitted. “And for five, four games, three games, we didn’t show what we’re capable of. Ultimately, that’s what we’re judged on.”
