The New York Knicks are facing elimination in the Eastern Conference Finals, and one NBA legend thinks he knows what could help.

Magic Johnson took to X, formerly known as Twitter, and suggested that the Knicks should bring Josh Hart back into the starting lineup for Game 5.

Johnson’s message was brief but direct.

“A message to the New York Knicks: Go back to what got you to the Eastern Conference Finals—that’s having Josh Hart in the starting lineup.”

Hart, a major contributor throughout New York’s playoff run, was shifted to the bench in Games 3 and 4 in favor of Mitchell Robinson. While the Knicks took Game 3 with Hart still playing 34 minutes and grabbing 10 rebounds, they struggled in Game 4, falling 130–121.

Article Continues Below
Related New York Knicks News
Indiana Pacers guard Bennedict Mathurin (00) shoots against New York Knicks center Mitchell Robinson (23) and guard Jalen Brunson (11) in the third quarter during game five of the eastern conference finals for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Madison Square Garden.
Knicks fans erupt after Mitchell Robinson’s violent Tyrese Haliburton blockLorenzo J Reyna ·
Richard Jefferson and Shaquille O'Neal look on before game five of the eastern conference finals for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Madison Square Garden.
Shaquille O’Neal issues fiery message on Inside the NBA’s futureLorenzo J Reyna ·
American filmmaker Spike Lee before game five of the eastern conference finals between the New York Knicks and the Indiana Pacers for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Madison Square Garden.
Spike Lee reveals what he’d give to see Knicks win NBA FinalsRichard Pereira ·
Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton (0) shoots a three point basket over New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11) during the fourth quarter of game four of the eastern conference finals for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.
Draymond Green puts blame for Knicks losses on coaching staffJackson Stone ·
New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11) fouls out of the game in the second half during game five of the second round for the 2025 NBA Playoffs against the Boston Celtics at TD Garden.
ESPN analyst defends Jalen Brunson with ‘very average’ Knicks claimJaren Kawada ·
New York Knicks center Karl-Anthony Towns (32) defends against Indiana Pacers forward Aaron Nesmith (23) in the first quarter during game one of the eastern conference finals for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Madison Square Garden.
Are Karl-Anthony Towns, Aaron Nesmith playing? Pacers-Knicks Game 5 injury reportMalik Brown ·

Hart’s role may have changed, but his influence remains significant. He continues to log substantial minutes off the bench, though removing him from the starting lineup may have disrupted New York’s rhythm—particularly noticeable in the flat start to Game 4.

Johnson’s suggestion echoes what many fans and analysts have observed. Hart’s energy and rebounding consistently help set the tone early, even when his scoring is limited. His ability to spark momentum and elevate defensive effort has been a hallmark of the Knicks’ success. Shifting that dynamic may have come at the wrong time.

With the crowd sure to be electric at Madison Square Garden, the Knicks will need to feed off that energy early. Momentum has swung firmly in the Indiana Pacer's favor, and a fast start could be critical to shifting the series narrative back in New York’s direction.

Now trailing 3–1 in the series, New York must respond with urgency. Indiana has looked dominant behind Tyrese Haliburton and Pascal Siakam, and they’re now just one win away from the NBA Finals. Returning to Madison Square Garden for Game 5, the Knicks will need everything to click if they want to stay alive.