The Toronto Raptors had all the right circumstances lined up for a second consecutive Game 1 victory this postseason after a 16-year tough luck streak without winning one in the postseason.

Yet as the game went on, it became more and more apparent that the team was about to squander that possibility, resulting in a 113-112 overtime defeat at the hands of the Cleveland Cavaliers.

Raptors coach Dwane Casey didn't know what to make of it during the post-game press conference, still dumbfounded at what took place on Tuesday night at the Air Canada Centre.

“I don't know if it was nerves, or yips, or what,” said Casey. “Things that just shot ourselves in the foot. We have a [13]-point lead in the third quarter… there's a lot of things that we can clean up.”

Article Continues Below
More Toronto Raptors News
Toronto Raptors vice chairman and team president Masai Ujiri talks to the media during media day at Scotiabank Area.
Masai Ujiri, Raptors part ways after 2025 NBA DraftPreston Byers ·
Florida Gators guard Alijah Martin (15) speaks to the media during a press conference for the men's 2025 NCAA tournament at Alamodome.
Raptors’ Alijah Martin sets record straight on Vince Carter’s jersey numberRichard Pereira ·
Florida Gators guard Alijah Martin (15) reacts after a play against the Houston Cougars during the second half of the national championship game of the Final Four of the 2025 NCAA Tournament at the Alamodome.
Raptors select Final Four history maker with No. 39 pickRichard Pereira ·
Toronto Raptors shooting guard RJ Barrett (9) shoots a jump shot against. Brooklyn Nets forward Noah Clowney (21) and Brooklyn Nets guard Tyson Eitenne (10) during the first half at Barclays Center.
Raptors add ACC DPOY after NBA DraftLorenzo J Reyna ·
South Carolina Gamecocks forward Chloe Kitts talks to media before practice at Amalie Arena.
South Carolina’s Chloe Kitts supports boyfriend Colin Murray-Boyles at NBA DraftJess Koffie ·
South Carolina Gamecocks head coach Dawn Staley reacts during the first quarter in a semifinal of the women's 2025 NCAA tournament against the Texas Longhorns at Amalie Arena.
Dawn Staley makes ‘sneaky’ Chloe Kitts-Colin Murray Boyles joke during draftZachary Draves ·

The Raptors had an exhausted LeBron James in their crosshair, struggling from the field after emptying the tank in a seven-game first-round series against the Indiana Pacers. Yet they weren't able to hold on to their lead, struggling to make shots from all around the floor with a hard-chasing Cleveland defense on its toes.

Toronto only made five field goals in the fourth quarter, seemingly having a lid on the basket, as the Cavaliers slowly closed the deficit, ending with a heavily-contested LeBron James fadeaway jumper to send the game to overtime.

The Raptors played from behind from there, unable to score in the last two minutes of the game and taking a painful loss in what's bound to be a tough series.