The Minnesota Twins are facing a major roadblock in their pursuit of AL Central dominance — an abysmal 16-34 record over their last 50 games against the Cleveland Guardians. That's a .320 win rate, the equivalent of a 52-110 season pace, and it underscores the gap between Minnesota and Cleveland in this divisional rivalry.

Since 2022, the Guardians have outplayed the Twins in nearly every facet, especially in tight contests. As Aaron Gleeman highlighted on X, formerly Twitter,

“#MNTwins are now 16-34 (.320) in their last 50 games against the Guardians.”

That includes a shocking 0-12 record in one-run games at Progressive Field, with eight ending in walk-offs. This recent stretch reflects deeper issues across multiple areas — bullpen reliability, clutch hitting, pitching rotation inconsistency, and mental resilience — which have combined to create a notable performance gap in this critical divisional rivalry. The Twins have consistently faltered in late-game situations, and their inability to execute under pressure has become a defining trait of these matchups.

Article Continues Below
More Minnesota Twins News
Minnesota Twins third baseman Royce Lewis (23) hits a RBI single against the Texas Rangers in the fourth inning at Target Field.
Twins’ Royce Lewis heads to IL with hamstring strainAlex House ·
Minnesota Twins outfielder Byron Buxton (25) runs off of the field before a game against the Baltimore Orioles at Oriole Park at Camden Yards.
Byron Buxton exits Twins-Astros game with apparent injuryJoey Mistretta ·
Minnesota Twins starting pitcher Bailey Ober (17) awaits the manager to get pulled from throwing to the Texas Rangers in the fifth inning.
Twins’ Bailey Ober makes admission after struggle vs. RangersJosh Davis ·
Minnesota Twins center fielder Byron Buxton (25) rounds third base to score on a single hit by first baseman Ty France (13) during the first inning against the Baltimore Orioles at Target Field.
Twins’ Rocco Baldelli gushes about ‘mesmerizing’ Byron Buxton performanceJedd Pagaduan ·
Minnesota Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers (27) celebrates with pitcher Jorge Alcala (66) after defeating the Cincinnati Reds at Target Field.
Red Sox trade with Twins to boost pitching depthScotty White ·
Minnesota Twins outfielder Byron Buxton (25) celebrates his three-run home run hit against the Seattle Mariners during the sixth inning at T-Mobile Park.
Twins’ Byron Buxton blasts 479 foot bomb vs. RangersJosh Davis ·

In 2024, the Twins went just 3-10 against Cleveland, dropping five one-run games and losing three via walk-offs. This trend cost them critical ground in the AL Central, a division where intra-division games often decide playoff fate. While Minnesota's pitching has been inconsistent, the Guardians have executed with precision– Tanner Bibee and Luis Ortiz silence the Twins' offense in key matchups.

Offensively, the Twins haven't delivered in clutch spots, while Cleveland's José Ramirez and Kyle Manzardo have come through repeatedly. Defensively, Minnesota's missteps — like base-running blunders and fielding errors — have widened the gap. Meanwhile, Cleveland has protected Progressive Field as a fortress.

In the 2025 standings, the Twins already trail the Guardians, sitting at 13-19 while Cleveland is in second place at 18-13. If Minnesota can't reverse this head-to-head trend, their playoff hopes are in jeopardy. Fixing the bullpen, improving situational hitting, and addressing mental lapses in one-run games are now mandatory.

With the AL Central race heating up, the Twins must adapt fast — or risk letting the Guardians control the division narrative yet again.