Subscribe
Follow Us
As Spring Training rapidly approaches, the San Francisco Giants still have an opportunity to make a significant move to bolster their roster. While they’ve made some key additions this offseason, including shortstop Willy Adames and veteran ace Justin Verlander, there’s still work to be done if they hope to compete in the highly competitive National League West.
One area that remains a concern is the outfield, specifically in terms of adding a true impact bat. Enter Chicago White Sox outfielder Luis Robert Jr., a dynamic talent who could provide the star power the Giants have long been searching for. Given the White Sox’s ongoing rebuild and willingness to move Robert for the right price, San Francisco should strike a deal. The trade proposal? The Giants send outfielder Mike Yastrzemski, first baseman LaMonte Wade Jr., closer Camilo Doval, and cash considerations to the White Sox in exchange for Robert and LHP Hagen Smith (34).
Why this trade makes sense for the Giants
The Giants need a legitimate offensive force to anchor their lineup, and Robert fits the bill. Despite a down 2024 season marred by injuries, the 27-year-old remains one of the most electrifying players in the league when healthy. Just a year prior, in 2023, he smashed 38 home runs with 80 RBIs and posted a .542 slugging percentage. That kind of power and production is something San Francisco sorely needs.
Adding Robert not only gives the Giants a premier bat but also an elite defensive center fielder. With Jung Hoo Lee expected to be the team’s primary center fielder, Robert could slide into left field or vice versa, giving San Francisco one of the best defensive outfields in baseball. A healthy Robert, combined with Adames and Matt Chapman on the left side of the infield, would significantly improve the Giants' defense.
Additionally, Robert’s contract is team-friendly. He’s signed through 2025 at $15 million, with club options for 2026 and 2027 at $20 million each. For a player with MVP-caliber upside, that’s a bargain the Giants should be eager to take advantage of.
Why this trade makes sense for the White Sox
The White Sox are in full rebuild mode, and Robert is their most valuable trade asset. However, with his injury history and the team’s current trajectory, Chicago may be better off flipping him for multiple assets rather than hoping he stays healthy and maintains peak value.
By acquiring Yastrzemski, Wade Jr., and Doval, the White Sox would get immediate contributors while also adding financial flexibility for their rebuild. Yastrzemski, while not a superstar, is a solid veteran who can provide leadership in the outfield and serve as a bridge while Chicago develops younger talent. Wade Jr. is a versatile bat who could slot into their everyday lineup at first base or in the outfield, adding left-handed power to a lineup that needs it.
Perhaps the biggest prize for Chicago in this trade is Camilo Doval. The hard-throwing right-hander has been one of the best closers in baseball over the past few seasons, and at just 27 years old, he still has plenty of upside. Given how valuable elite relievers are, especially in the postseason, the White Sox could either build around Doval as their closer of the future or flip him for additional assets at the trade deadline.
The risks and considerations
For the Giants, the biggest risk in this trade is Robert’s health. He played only 100 games in 2024, dealing with a hip injury that impacted his performance. If those durability concerns continue, San Francisco could find itself in a difficult position. However, his immense upside makes the risk worthwhile. At the same time, they're adding depth to the farm system with Smith.
Additionally, trading Doval would mean losing one of baseball’s best closers, but the Giants have shown a knack for developing bullpen talent. Ryan Walker emerged as a dominant force in 2024 and could step into the closer role, while the team could also explore free-agent or trade options to fill the void.
From the White Sox’s perspective, parting with a player of Robert’s caliber is never easy. However, given their long-term outlook, getting multiple quality pieces in return—especially a closer like Doval—would be a strong return.
If the Giants are serious about contending in 2025 and beyond, this is the type of bold move they need to make. Adding Luis Robert Jr. would give them a legitimate superstar talent, boosting both their lineup and defense. While it would hurt to part with Doval, Wade Jr., and Yastrzemski, the potential reward outweighs the risk. San Francisco has spent years searching for a game-changing bat, and Robert could be the answer. If the Giants want to keep pace in the NL West, they need to take a swing—literally and figuratively—before Spring Training begins.