Subscribe
Follow Us
The Dallas Cowboys' decision to part ways with head coach Mike McCarthy has sparked a flurry of reactions across the NFL, including from franchise legend Troy Aikman. During an appearance on ESPN's Monday Night Countdown, Aikman shared pointed comments about the state of the Cowboys organization, casting doubt on whether the team’s head coaching position is as desirable as its storied history might suggest.
“I thought Mike McCarthy would be the head coach, so this is a bit of a surprise for me today,” Aikman said. “It suggests that there's not a real plan.”
McCarthy and the Cowboys parted ways on Monday after failing to reach an agreement on a contract extension, ending a tenure that saw some success but fell short of delivering Dallas to the Super Bowl. Aikman, who won three Super Bowls as the Cowboys’ quarterback, expressed admiration for McCarthy, describing him as an “outstanding football coach” who has proven himself in the league.
However, Aikman noted that coaching in Dallas comes with unique challenges, particularly concerning the dynamics of power and control within the organization.
“You also have to empower that head coach,” Aikman said. “And that's been what has been missing in Dallas since Jimmy Johnson walked out the door.”
The remark points to a long-standing criticism of how the Cowboys operate under team owner and general manager Jerry Jones. Since Johnson’s departure in 1994, the Cowboys have cycled through multiple head coaches without replicating the sustained success of their 1990s dynasty. Aikman’s comments suggest that the lack of autonomy for head coaches remains a key issue in Dallas.
When asked about whether the Cowboys’ head coaching job remains “coveted,” Aikman was skeptical. “As far as a coveted job … I don't know that's accurate,” he said.
Aikman’s skepticism is notable given his deep ties to the franchise and his understanding of its culture. While the Cowboys’ history, resources, and massive fan base make the role appealing on paper, the intense scrutiny, high expectations, and potential for limited control could make it less attractive to top candidates.
The Cowboys’ search for a new head coach now begins under these circumstances, with Jones and the front office facing pressure to find a leader capable of breaking through decades of playoff struggles. Potential candidates will need to weigh the prestige of coaching “America’s Team” against the challenges of navigating its internal politics.
For fans, Aikman’s candid assessment highlights a sobering reality: while the Cowboys may still be one of the NFL’s most iconic franchises, the path to success in Dallas remains anything but straightforward. Whether the next head coach can overcome those hurdles remains to be seen.
