The Indianapolis Colts approach the 2025 offseason at a critical crossroads. After another season of inconsistent performances and missed playoff aspirations, the team is poised to make impactful moves. With a dedicated fanbase eager for a resurgence and a roster anchored by rising stars like quarterback Anthony Richardson and wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr, the Colts are positioned to take the next step. However, achieving this will require shrewd decision-making in free agency. Below are the top targets Indianapolis should consider to address their needs and strengthen their roster.
Battling Through Challenges
The Colts faced hurdles in 2024 with Richardson’s development and a defense that ranked among the league’s bottom tier in several categories. Despite that, the Colts managed to hover near .500 once again. Their 8-9 record ensured the return of head coach Shane Steichen and general manager Chris Ballard for another season. However, the pressure is mounting for this duo to field a competitive team. They also need to foster significant progress in Richardson’s third year.

The Colts’ financial position sits in the league’s middle tier regarding cap space. Sure, they benefit from having a starting quarterback on a rookie contract. However, they also carry hefty financial commitments. These include over $20 million allocated to DeForest Buckner, Michael Pittman Jr, and Quenton Nelson.
Here we'll look at the players who should be among the Indianapolis Colts' top NFL free agency targets as the 2025 offseason begins.
Defensive Playmaker
A significant area of concern for the Colts lies in their secondary, particularly at the safety position. San Francisco 49ers standout Talanoa Hufanga could be the answer to solidify this unit. The Colts’ secondary has shown potential at cornerback with promising young talent. However, safety remains a glaring weakness. If Julian Blackmon is not re-signed, the Colts must prioritize safety in free agency.
Yes, Hufanga was limited to seven games this past season due to injury. However, he is still a proven playmaker. At 26, he brings valuable experience from his time with the 49ers’ strong defensive unit. Signing Hufanga would not only fill a critical need. It would also eliminate safety as a draft priority. This would allow Indianapolis to focus on other areas while significantly upgrading their secondary.
Bolstering the Linebacker Corps
The Colts also have an opportunity to enhance their linebacker unit. Nick Bolton from the Kansas City Chiefs is an ideal candidate. Remember that EJ Speed’s future uncertain as he heads into free agency. As such, Indianapolis needs an infusion of youth and dynamic talent on defense. Bolton fits the bill perfectly. He brings elite playmaking ability and sideline-to-sideline speed. He’s the type of impactful addition that is feasible while Richardson remains on his rookie deal. Bolton’s track record of consistency and high performance makes him worth the investment. His presence could elevate the Colts’ defensive capabilities.
Exploring Quarterback Options
Sure, Anthony Richardson is the centerpiece of the Colts’ long-term plans at quarterback. That said, adding a capable backup or competition could benefit both the player and the team. Justin Fields could be an intriguing option here. He is likely to hit the free-agent market after being benched for Russell Wilson in Pittsburgh. Fields offers a dual-threat skill set and has demonstrated efficiency and consistency throughout his career.
Fields and Richardson share similar playing styles. This makes Fields an excellent addition for multiple reasons. He could serve as a mentor, helping Richardson refine his game, or even compete for the starting role if needed. Fields would bring depth and stability to the quarterback room. He could also ensure the Colts have a reliable option under center.
Strengthening the Tight End Position
Tight end has been an inconsistent position for the Colts. That makes it a key area to address this offseason. Zach Ertz, a veteran with a proven track record, could provide an immediate boost. Yes, Mo Alie-Cox and Drew Ogletree are reliable blockers. However, their contributions in the passing game have been underwhelming. And with Kylen Granson’s contract expiring, the Colts could look to move on.
Remember that Ertz is a three-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion. He will hit free agency after his contract with the Washington Commanders expires. Despite being 34, he remains productive. His experience and leadership could be invaluable for mentoring younger tight ends like Ogletree while adding a dependable receiving threat for Richardson. Ertz’s blend of talent and experience would immediately upgrade this position.
Seizing the Moment
To maximize their offseason moves, the Colts must ensure their acquisitions align with their broader vision. Players like Hufanga, Bolton, Fields, and Ertz not only address critical needs. They can also complement the team’s culture and long-term goals. Signing proven talents who fill immediate gaps while supporting the development of the roster’s core pieces will position Indianapolis as a serious contender in the AFC.
The 2025 offseason presents a golden opportunity for the Colts to break free from mediocrity and build a championship-caliber team. Pursuing high-impact players such as Hufanga, Bolton, Fields, and Ertz could energize the franchise, solidify the roster, and lay the groundwork for sustained success. The road to the Super Bowl begins now, and the decisions made in the coming months will determine whether the Colts rise to the challenge or remain stuck in the middle of the pack. For a team and a fanbase hungry for success, there’s no better time to act than the present.