New York Yankees superstar Aaron Judge cruised to his second career AL MVP Award last season, winning the honor unanimously. The Bronx bomber led the majors in just about every meaningful offensive category in 2024 as he and one-year rental Juan Soto dragged New York to the World Series. But Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. impressed as well, easily edging out Soto for second in MVP voting.

Despite Judge’s continued dominance as he enters his age-33 season, a passing of the torch could be on the horizon. Witt Jr. surprisingly surpassed Judge as the betting favorite to take home AL MVP honors in 2025, according to FanDuel.

The sports betting behemoth now gives Witt Jr. +270 odds to win the award while Judge is right behind him at +300. After the top two American League players, there’s a bit of a drop off. The Orioles’ Gunnar Henderson is next with +750 odds followed by the Rangers’ Corey Seager at +1000 and the Astros’ Yordan Alvarez at +1400, per FanDuel.

Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. takes over as favorite for 2025 AL MVP

Oct 2, 2024; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. (7) hits a single in the third inning against the Baltimore Orioles in game two of the Wild Card round for the 2024 MLB Playoffs at Oriole Park at Camden Yards.
Tommy Gilligan-Imagn Images
Article Continues Below
More Betting News
Hill Rountree prediction, UFC Baku odds
Jamahal Hill vs. Khalil Rountree Jr. prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuDominik Zawartko ·
Fiziev Bahamondes prediction, ufc baku odds
Rafael Fiziev vs. Ignacio Bahamondes prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuGarrett Kerman ·
Blaydes Kuniev prediction, ufc baku odds
Curtis Blaydes vs. Rizvan Kuniev prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuJaren Kawada ·
Orolbai Musayev prediction, ufc baku odds
Myktybek Orolbai vs. Tofiq Musayev prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuGarrett Kerman ·
Sadykhov Motta prediction, UFC Baku odds
Nazim Sadykhov vs. Nikolas Motta prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuDominik Zawartko ·
Naimov Grad prediction, UFC Baku odds
Muhammad Naimov vs. Bogdan Grad prediction, odds, pick for UFC BakuDominik Zawartko ·

Last season Judge led all of MLB in WAR (10.8), home runs (58), RBI (144), walks (133), OBP (.458), slugging percentage (.701), OPS (1.159), OPS+ (223) and rOBA (.484). He was tops in the American League with 392 total bases, trailing only Shohei Ohtani’s MLB-leading 411 total bags.

Meanwhile, Witt Jr. infused Royals fans with hope for the first time in years. The third-year pro led Kansas City to its first playoff appearance in nine seasons. The Royals even won the Wild Card series against the Orioles before falling to the Yankees in the Division round.

Witt Jr. continued his ascent to stardom, winning his first batting title, making his first All-Star Game and earning his first Gold Glove. He also made MLB history, becoming the first player to ever hit 20 or more home runs and steal 20 or more bases in each of his first three seasons. He would finish the year as the only shortstop to ever have multiple 30/30 seasons.

Despite Witt Jr.’s incredible individual success, which was a major catalyst for the team's success, the 24-year-old slugger was listed as just the fourth-best shortstop in baseball according to MLB Network. Henderson, Seager and Francisco Lindor were all listed above him and he came in just one spot ahead of Mookie Betts, who’s spent the vast majority of his career not playing shortstop.