Tony Pollard's transition to the Tennessee Titans signals the end of the Derrick Henry era. In a move to solidify their backfield, the Titans have secured the services of the former Dallas Cowboys running back through a lucrative three-year contract worth $24 million. Sure, there was speculation about Henry's potential return. However, it now seems improbable. Pollard's recent performance with the Cowboys showcases his capability as a starting running back. This was particularly evident in his 1,005 rushing yards and six touchdowns last season. That marked his second consecutive year surpassing the 1,000-yard mark.

The Titans' 2023 Season

The Tennessee Titans endured a rollercoaster 2023 season. It was marked by both triumphs and setbacks. It ultimately concluded with a disappointing 6-11 record and missing out on the playoffs. Despite standout moments from key players like Derrick Henry and DeAndre Hopkins, injuries and inconsistent displays plagued the team. These were most notable on the defensive end. As the Titans seek to regroup for the upcoming season, there are evident areas requiring attention to ensure a more fruitful campaign ahead.

Pollard's Path to Tennessee

Having played the previous season under the $10.1 million franchise tag, Pollard's new contract likely offers increased guaranteed money. That's despite representing a decrease in annual salary. Take note that, among active NFL running backs, only a select few, including Christian McCaffrey and Alvin Kamara, boast higher average annual contracts. Pollard's trajectory from backup to standout in Dallas underscores his potential. This came despite initial struggles following a leg injury. With his arrival in Tennessee, Pollard should fill the void left by Henry. Again, this signals a new chapter for the Titans' backfield.

According to reports, the Titans will compensate Pollard with a $24 million contract spanning three years. This positions him among the top 10 highest-paid running backs in the NFL as of Monday. Turning 27 in April, Pollard boasts consecutive seasons of over 1,000 rushing yards, albeit with less wear on his legs compared to some of his peers in this offseason's market.

Given his solitary season as the primary starter in Dallas, it's anticipated that Pollard will share playing time with second-year Titans running back Tyjae Spears. We do not expect Pollard to fully assume the role of RB1 in Coach Brian Callahan's offensive scheme for the Titans.

Here we will look at and grade running back Tony Pollard's 3-year, $24 million contract with the Tennessee Titans.

Grade: B

Sensible Move

Tony Pollard's return to his hometown team marks a sensible move for the Titans. A versatile running back, Pollard has showcased consistency with 1,007 and 1,005 rushing yards in the past two seasons. That's coupled with 94 receptions for 682 yards, highlighting his dual-threat capabilities. By securing Pollard, the Titans emphasize their commitment to running backs proficient in the passing game, complementing similar attributes seen in Spears. Despite Pollard's slightly diminished performance in 2023 as the lead back for the Cowboys, his potential to share carries with Spears presents a promising scenario.

Areas of Consideration

Yes, Pollard's arrival suggests a rotation in the backfield. Still, allocating significant funds to a part-time rusher raises concerns. Take note that the ability to rotate enhances versatility. On the flip side, the similarity in playing style between Pollard and Spears may limit diversity in offensive strategy. Additionally, the substantial investment in the running back position prompts speculation about alternative budget allocations. This is especially true considering other pressing needs on offense and defense. Nonetheless, the Titans' apparent preference for Spears in a shared role over a primary back indicates a strategic direction for the team.

Green Bay Packers safety Jonathan Owens (34) tackles Dallas Cowboys running back Tony Pollard (20) in the first half of the 2024 NFC wild card game at AT&T Stadium
Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports

Compatibility

The Titans' ability to interchange Pollard and Spears presents a favorable dynamic. This can potentially alter the team's offensive approach under Coach Callahan. Despite the relatively high financial commitment to the running back position, Pollard's projected production of 1,000 rushing yards and 50 receptions justifies the investment. This should align with the team's offensive objectives.

In summary, sure, the Titans' expenditure on running backs may seem excessive given other positional requirements. However, the acquisition of a dual-threat talent like Pollard offers versatility and strategic benefits to the team's evolving offensive scheme.

Looking Ahead

We know that Tony Pollard's contract may not be without its critiques or uncertainties. However, its overall impact and potential benefits outweigh any perceived drawbacks. With a solid “B” grade assigned to this deal, it is evident that both parties have made a calculated investment in each other's success. As fans eagerly anticipate seeing Pollard donning the Titans jersey on game day, there is an air of excitement and optimism surrounding his role within the team. Only time will tell how this partnership unfolds. That said, one thing remains certain – Tony Pollard's journey with the Tennessee Titans should be an intriguing chapter in their quest for NFL glory.